Bombay High Court Imposes Fine on ED for Unjustly Probing Real Estate Developer
The Bombay High Court has criticized and fined the Directorate of Enforcement (ED) for conducting an investigation against a real estate developer without sufficient evidence, under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA).
Bombay High CourtEdReal Estate DeveloperPrevention Of Money Laundering ActPmlaReal EstateJan 23, 2025
The court has imposed a fine of Rs 1 lakh on the national agency, highlighting the misuse of power and lack of proper legal justification.
The case involves a property dispute between Mumbai-based real estate developer Rakesh Jain and property purchaser Gul Achhra.
Achhra had plans to develop a hotel on the floors of a building in Mumbai’s Malad area.
However, due to delays in obtaining an occupation certificate, Achhra filed a complaint with the Mumbai Police.
The matter was subsequently escalated to the Andheri magistrate court, which directed the Vile Parle police to investigate the issue.
The investigation was later handed over to the ED, which alleged that Jain’s purchase of flats and a garage in Andheri during the dispute constituted ‘proceeds of crime’.
The Bombay High Court, in its judgment, noted that both the ED and the complainant, Gul Achhra, acted with malafide intentions.
The single-judge Bench of Justice Milind Jadhav imposed a fine of Rs 1 lakh each on the national agency and the complainant.
The court termed the case as a classic example of oppression carried out under the guise of implementing the PMLA.
It was observed that Achhra manipulated the system by suppressing the findings of the police, which had already ruled the matter as civil in nature.
The court further pointed out that Achhra had a clear ulterior motive, which became evident as the case progressed.
Justice Jadhav emphasized that law enforcement agencies like the ED should conduct themselves within the legal framework and cannot take the law into their own hands without due application of mind.
The court noted that merely breaching an agreement does not amount to a criminal breach of trust under Section 406 of the Indian Penal Code.
The High Court also declared the magistrate’s order to involve the Vile Parle police as beyond its jurisdiction and deemed the case filed by the police and the subsequent investigation by the ED as invalid.
This judgment sends a strong message to law enforcement agencies and highlights the importance of adhering to the principles of justice and fairness in legal proceedings.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why did the Bombay High Court fine the Directorate of Enforcement (ED)?
The Bombay High Court fined the ED for initiating an investigation against a real estate developer without adequate evidence, under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA). The court found that the ED and the complainant acted with malafide intentions.
What was the property dispute about?
The property dispute involved a real estate developer, Rakesh Jain, and a property purchaser, Gul Achhra, who planned to develop a hotel on the floors of a building in Mumbai’s Malad area. Delays in obtaining an occupation certificate led to the dispute.
What did the court say about the complainant's actions?
The court observed that the complainant, Gul Achhra, manipulated the system by suppressing police findings, which had ruled the matter as civil in nature. The court noted that Achhra had a clear ulterior motive.
What was the role of the Andheri magistrate court?
The Andheri magistrate court directed the Vile Parle police to investigate the matter, which was later transferred to the ED. The High Court declared this order as beyond the magistrate’s jurisdiction.
What is the significance of this judgment?
This judgment sends a strong message to law enforcement agencies and highlights the importance of adhering to the principles of justice and fairness in legal proceedings. It emphasizes that agencies like the ED should conduct themselves within the legal framework.
Related News Articles
Justo Realfintech Expands Footprint in Pune and Thane with Mega Mandate
Real estate services startup Justo Realfintech secures developer mandates worth over Rs 1400 crore in Pune and Thane
Reviving Stalled Real Estate Projects: NCLT Approves Alchemist Infra Realty's Acquisition
The acquisition of Alchemist Infra Realty Ltd by Vantage Point Asset Management Pte Ltd has been approved by the National Company Law Tribunal, paving the way for the revival of stalled real estate projects.
Indian Housing Market Sees 12% YoY Price Growth in Q2 2024
Strong demand from homebuyers drives housing prices up 12% year-on-year in April-June quarter, while unsold inventory dips across major cities.
Man Wins Rs 1.2 Crore Lottery with Rs 835 Ticket After Selling Pumpkin
In a miraculous turn of events, a man from a small village in India has won Rs 1.2 crore in the lottery with just a Rs 835 ticket. What makes this story even more incredible is that he had to sell a pumpkin to afford the ticket.
Mumbai's Real Estate Market: Property Registrations See a 5% Increase in November
In a surprising turn of events, property registrations in Mumbai saw a 5% increase in November, recording over 10,200 units. This positive trend comes despite a slight decline from the previous month's figures.
Luxury Juhu Apartment Sells for ₹106.52 Crore in Major Real Estate Deal
In one of the most significant real estate transactions in Mumbai, a luxury apartment in Juhu has been sold for an impressive ₹106.52 crore, setting a new benchmark in the city's residential market.