Bombay High Court Ruling on JDAs: A Boon for Real Estate Developers and Homebuyers
The Bombay High Court's decision that GST will apply only at the property transfer stage in joint development agreements (JDAs) is expected to ease financial burdens, enhance project viability, and provide greater pricing predictability for homebuyers.
Real EstateGstJoint Development AgreementsBombay High CourtHomebuyersReal EstateSep 12, 2025
However, legal experts cautioned that larger questions on the eligibility of input tax credit will require clarity, along with an eventual decision from the Supreme Court as the ruling may be challenged in the apex court.
Mayank Arora, Partner at The Chambers of Bharat Chugh, said that given the Centre’s fiscal stake in GST collections, an appeal before the Supreme Court cannot be ruled out.
“By their own admission, GST authorities have conceded that the interpretation as upheld in the judgement is the correct position of law, thereby curtailing litigation on this subject. But, the last word has not yet been spoken. Given the Centre’s fiscal stake in GST collections, an appeal before the Supreme Court cannot be ruled out,” he said.
The debate also extends to whether the burden of tax, if at all upheld, falls on the landowner or the developer, and how the valuation of such rights can be determined when no separate consideration is charged for any so-called service element. Following the Supreme Court’s eventual determination, another layer of complexity will emerge in relation to the eligibility of input tax credit, which will have to be tested on the touchstone of the ‘functionality’ and ‘essentiality’ principles, said Abhishek A Rastogi, founder of Rastogi Chambers.
He added that while the ruling provides breathing room for developers, each case will demand a fact-specific examination, making the issue far more intricate than it appears at first glance.
“Uniformity of interpretation across jurisdiction will be vital to avoid a patchwork of conflicting rulings,” Arora said.
Prateek Bansal, Partner at White & Brief-Advocates and Solicitors, said the ruling will ease financial stress during the construction period, making the JDA model more attractive.
Ayush Mehrotra, partner at Khaitan & Co, added that it prevents double taxation and ensures smoother execution.
“Developers now have certainty on the tax treatment of JDAs, which helps control costs and ultimately benefits homebuyers. The clarity will influence ongoing and future projects, making the sector more efficient and investor-friendly,” he said.
The Bombay High Court’s Goa bench on Thursday ruled that developers do not need to pay GST on construction services under a JDA until the completed property is transferred through a registered conveyance. The tax department’s earlier stand was that GST was due when the JDA was signed.
Developers said that the ruling offered relief from cash flow issues upon signing a development agreement, with GST no longer needed to be deposited at inception when neither construction nor sale of units had commenced.
Cyrus Mody, founder and chief executive officer of Viceroy Properties, said the verdict brings “fairness and predictability” to taxation.
“For us, this reduces one of the most pressing cost pressures and allows us to focus on design excellence and timely delivery. For homebuyers, especially in luxury markets, it ensures transparency, faster execution, and more stable pricing,” he added.
Developers estimate the relief could unlock savings in large-scale redevelopments, and some relief for homebuyers who end up bearing the passed down high costs of construction.
Sujay Kalele, founder and managing director of Tru Realty, said, “With JDAs covering over 1,500 acres and a gross development value of nearly ₹1 trillion, this translates into hundreds of crores being channelled back into construction and delivery. For homebuyers, it reduces pricing pressure at a time when construction costs have already risen 40 per cent in the past five years.”
Manan Shah, managing director of MICL Group, added that most major land transactions in metro cities now rely on JDAs.
“This judgment brings overdue clarity for developers and landowners structuring projects, especially in dense urban markets like Mumbai, Bengaluru, and Hyderabad,” he noted.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the impact of the Bombay High Court's ruling on GST for JDAs?
The ruling states that GST will apply only at the stage of property transfer in joint development agreements (JDAs), which eases financial burdens, improves project viability, and provides greater pricing predictability for homebuyers.
Why might the ruling be challenged in the Supreme Court?
Legal experts caution that the ruling may be challenged in the Supreme Court due to the Centre's fiscal stake in GST collections and the need for clarity on input tax credit eligibility.
How does the ruling benefit developers and homebuyers?
Developers benefit from reduced financial stress during the construction period, and homebuyers benefit from more stable pricing and transparency in the development process.
What does the ruling mean for the real estate sector?
The ruling brings clarity to the tax treatment of JDAs, making the sector more efficient and investor-friendly, and influencing ongoing and future projects.
How does the ruling affect large-scale redevelopments?
The ruling is expected to unlock savings in large-scale redevelopments, providing some relief for homebuyers who bear the high costs of construction.
Related News Articles
BJP's Allies in Trouble: Ruchir Sharma Decodes Lok Sabha Elections 2024
Ruchir Sharma predicts BJP's allies in Bihar
Sebi Chief Madhabi Buch's Stake in Consulting Firm Under Scrutiny
Madhabi Puri Buch, the chief of India's capital markets regulator, owns 99% of a Mumbai-based consulting firm that's now caught in the crossfire of the Hindenburg Research-Adani Group controversy.
Maharashtra Deputy Speaker and 3 Others Jump from Third Floor of Mantralaya in Protest
In a shocking turn of events, Maharashtra Deputy Speaker Narhari Zirwal and three other legislators jumped from the third floor of Mantralaya, the state secretariat, while protesting against the government's consideration of including the Dhangar communit
Mumbai's Festive Season Boosts Property Market, Driving Real Estate Growth
Mumbai, India's largest and most expensive property market, has seen a significant surge in home buying during the festive season, leading to a robust growth in the real estate sector.
How U.S. Foreign Investment Policies Could Reshape NRI Real Estate Investment in India
NRI investments in Indian property, particularly in cities like Bangalore, Hyderabad, and Pune, have been generating consistent rental yields. Discover how new U.S. foreign investment policies could reshape these trends.
Co-Living Startup Truliv Expands to Bengaluru
Truliv, a leading co-living startup based in Pune, has announced its expansion to Bengaluru, aiming to tap into the city’s thriving tech parks and urban living market.