China's Economic Stimulus Boosts Steel Prices, but Concerns Persist
China's latest economic stimulus measures have provided a short-term boost to steel prices, driven by infrastructure spending and interest rate cuts, but concerns remain about the sustainability of this trend.
Real Estate:Steel prices had been on a downward trend, but experts agree that China’s recent stimulus has lifted global sentiment. According to data from BigMint, a market intelligence and price reporting firm, since the third week of September, prices of hot-rolled coil (HRC) – a benchmark for flat steel – increased by about Rs 1,500 per tonne ex-Mumbai to Rs 48,600 per tonne.
The increase comes as China announced a monetary stimulus package and property market measures, including mortgage rate cuts, in late September. A BigMint analyst said China’s latest economic stimulus measures provided a short-term boost to steel prices, driven by infrastructure spending and interest rate cuts.
However, despite early optimism, the overall market response has been cautious, with sustained price recovery hinging on further policy actions and improvements in real estate demand, the analyst added.
In long steel, rebar prices have increased by Rs 3,600 per tonne ex-Mumbai to Rs 53,600 per tonne, BigMint data showed. This could be due to the revival of construction activities post-monsoon.
Steel prices had been on a downward trend, and experts agree that China’s stimulus has boosted global sentiment. In the last fortnight, the world’s second-largest steelmaker, ArcelorMittal, announced a price increase. Sumit Jhunjhunwala, assistant vice president at ICRA, said that steel prices in China had increased by 16 per cent since the announcement of the stimulus package. “This will drive prices globally. In India, prices have increased by about 4 to 5 per cent, even though some increase was expected post-monsoon.”
The big question, however, is whether this will be sustained. Sehul Bhatt, director of research at CRISIL Market Intelligence and Analytics, said the positive sentiment surrounding the stimulus led traders to increase steel prices. “However, this price rally will be short-lived, as the impact of the positive sentiment fades and supply and demand rebalance. The recent price hike has also narrowed the price differential between imported and domestically manufactured flat steel,” he added.
Even though sentiment has picked up and helped push prices higher in the domestic market, steel producers are concerned that it will not help check imports into India, which have been negatively impacting domestic prices. China’s steel exports, currently between 110 and 115 million tonnes, are expected to remain high, according to Ranjan Dhar, director and vice president of sales and marketing at ArcelorMittal Nippon Steel India (AM/NS India). “While China’s stimulus measures may boost domestic consumption, particularly of long steel, the country is unlikely to significantly curb exports to the global market unless it reduces production by 5 to 7 per cent.”
Global steel markets are becoming increasingly competitive. Countries are either imposing trade barriers or increasing their own production, reducing the demand for Chinese steel. This makes India, a rapidly growing market, more vulnerable. India must proactively implement safeguard measures to reduce its reliance on imports and promote domestic steel production to ensure ‘Aatmanirbharta’ and long-term competitiveness, Dhar added.
Another major steel producer said it was imperative for India to take action on imports. “Otherwise, India will become a dumping ground because surplus steel from the rest of the world will flow into the country, as other economies are still facing challenges.”
Alok Sahay, secretary-general of the Indian Steel Association, pointed out that Chinese exports are a concern for all economies. “The US, Canada, and the European Union have taken concrete measures by imposing a 25 per cent safeguard duty, and now Turkey has levied up to 43 per cent of dumping duty.”
“India has no safeguard measures against the surge in imports from China. We are exposed to the trade distortion caused by China,” he added.
Frequently Asked Questions
How has China's economic stimulus affected steel prices?
China's economic stimulus, including infrastructure spending and interest rate cuts, has provided a short-term boost to steel prices, particularly in the hot-rolled coil (HRC) and rebar segments.
What are the concerns with the price increase in steel?
The main concern is whether the price increase will be sustained, as it hinges on further policy actions and improvements in real estate demand. Additionally, there are concerns about the impact of high Chinese steel exports on global markets, including India.
Why are Indian steel producers worried about Chinese imports?
Indian steel producers are concerned that while the price increase is boosting sentiment, it may not help check imports, which have been negatively impacting domestic prices. This makes India more vulnerable to becoming a dumping ground for surplus steel from other economies.
What measures have other countries taken to address Chinese steel imports?
Other countries such as the US, Canada, and the European Union have imposed safeguard duties (25 per cent) and dumping duties (up to 43 per cent) to protect their domestic steel industries from Chinese imports.
What does India need to do to protect its steel industry?
India needs to proactively implement safeguard measures to reduce its reliance on imports and promote domestic steel production. This would help ensure ‘Aatmanirbharta’ (self-reliance) and long-term competitiveness in the global steel market.