High Court Dismisses Pleas Against Builder in WWII Land Rehabilitation Case
The Bombay High Court has dismissed a series of petitions, including two PILs, challenging the development rights of a builder tasked with rehabilitating villagers whose land was requisitioned during World War II and later used for the National Defence Academy in Pune.
Land RehabilitationWorld War IiNational Defence AcademyBombay High CourtKakade ConstructionReal Estate PuneNov 02, 2025
The land in question was requisitioned by the British government in 1942 for World War II and later acquired for the NDA in 1951. To rehabilitate the affected villagers, land was procured at Mouje Hingane Budruk, Pune, in 1961. In 2001, the development of this land was handed over to Kakade Construction Co Pvt Ltd under an agreement with the villagers.
In 2018, some people claiming to be the heirs of the original affected villagers filed a petition alleging that the developer engaged in fraud, forgery, and manipulation of land records. They claimed that the rehabilitation scheme was not implemented as promised and sought the revocation of the development rights granted to the builder. The High Court clubbed this petition with another filed in 2019 and two PILs filed in 2009 and 2023 by two foundations on the same issue.
A bench of Chief Justice Shree Chandrashekhar and Justice Gautam Ankhad, in its recent order, observed that such allegations of forgery and manipulation of records required detailed evidence and could only be examined by a civil court, not through a PIL. The court stated, 'The allegations of forgery and manipulation of records shall be the subject before the civil court where parties shall lead evidence. This is also a well-settled proposition in law that the writ petition involving dispute over immovable property shall not be maintainable.'
The High Court noted that a 2013 report by the Pune collector, placed before it in April, indicated that 315 out of 350 families had been rehabilitated. The court directed the builder to comply with the collector's report for the remaining 35 families. It also heard arguments from advocates Prathamesh Bhargude, Prabhakar Jadhav, and Sanjay Koban for the petitioners and recorded the submission of the builder's advocate, Karan Bhosale, that six of the 35 families had already been offered possession of flats.
At this stage, with the project almost complete, the High Court held that no order could be passed that would completely wash out the project. The court further stated, 'In our opinion, these PILs are not at all maintainable since the aggrieved persons have a remedy in law to approach the appropriate court.'
Frequently Asked Questions
What was the original purpose of the land requisitioned during World War II?
The land was originally requisitioned by the British government in 1942 for use during World War II and later acquired for the National Defence Academy (NDA) in 1951.
Who is responsible for the rehabilitation of the affected villagers?
The rehabilitation of the affected villagers from Kopare village in Pune was handed over to Kakade Construction Co Pvt Ltd in 2001 under an agreement with the villagers.
What were the main allegations raised in the petitions?
The main allegations raised in the petitions included fraud, forgery, and manipulation of land records, with the petitioners claiming that the rehabilitation scheme was not implemented as promised.
Why did the High Court dismiss the petitions?
The High Court dismissed the petitions because the allegations of forgery and manipulation of records required detailed evidence and could only be examined by a civil court, not through a PIL.
What was the outcome of the 2013 report by the Pune collector?
The 2013 report by the Pune collector indicated that 315 out of 350 families had been rehabilitated, and the court directed the builder to comply with the report for the remaining 35 families.
Related News Articles
Why India's Top IT Firms Are Shrinking Their Office Spaces
As the IT services sector reports its weakest-ever dollar revenue growth, companies like Cognizant, Infosys, and Wipro are reducing their office spaces to optimize costs.
IT Department Clarifies LTCG Calculations for Pre-2001 Real Estate
The IT Department has clarified the Long-Term Capital Gains (LTCG) calculations for properties acquired before 2001, allowing taxpayers to consider the fair market value of the property as on 1st April 2001.
Pune Property Registrations Plunge by 33% in September 2024
Pune witnessed a significant drop in property sale registrations, with only 11,056 units registered in September 2024, a 33% decline from the previous year.
Top 26 Listed Real Estate Firms in India Sell Properties Worth Rs 34,985 Crore in Q3 2024
India's leading 26 listed real estate firms collectively sold properties worth Rs 34,985 crore during the July-September 2024 quarter, showcasing a robust performance in the sector.
Residential Real Estate Sales Decline in 9MFY25: Report
Residential real estate sales volumes have seen a decline in the first nine months of FY25, but overall collections continue to rise, with Bengaluru remaining a key market.
Nifty Bulls Gear Up to Halt Eight-Day Market Slump
Explore the latest stock market trends and updates, including significant movements in Real Estate, NTPC, RailTel, NCC, Mazagon Dock, Dalmia Bharat, Hyundai Motor India, Voltas, Ujjivan Small Finance Bank, Mankind Pharma, and IRFC.