Is Now the Time to Shift from Direct REITs to Mutual Funds?
With volatile real estate markets and evolving tax rules, investors are weighing the trade-off between direct REIT holdings and diversified mutual fund exposure.
ReitsMutual FundsReal EstateInvestment StrategiesTax ImplicationsReal Estate NewsSep 21, 2025
Mutual funds, particularly real estate or hybrid schemes, are gaining traction because they allow diversification outside the ambit of a single industry. Although REITs are highly dependent on rents and property cycles, mutual funds spread the risk between equities, debt, and even real estate exposure in some instances. In today's uncertain environment, with commercial leasing under pressure and interest rates at a high, mutual funds can provide more stability through professional management and lower dependence on property cycles.
Tax rules also apply with the decision. REIT dividends are typically taxed in the shareholder's hands, and there are specific holding period requirements for capital gains on selling units. Mutual funds, however, have more structured tax treatment based on whether they are debt or equity oriented. For individuals in higher tax brackets, shifting some of their ownership from direct REITs into mutual funds could realize better after-tax returns.
Whether to switch or not depends on your investment horizon and expectations of the market. REITs still have potential for stable rental return as India's office space rebuilds, but mutual funds provide diversification at a time when interest rate volatility and regulatory change affect REIT performance. Rather than an exit, selective exposure—retaining some exposure to REITs but adding mutual funds—can strike a balance between risk and capturing opportunities across assets.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are REITs riskier than mutual funds?
Yes, REITs are more concentrated in commercial real estate, so the risks of vacancy, interest rate, or sector slowdown are higher. Mutual funds spread investments over industries, minimizing overall portfolio risk.
Do mutual funds offer exposure to real estate like REITs?
Not necessarily. Even though REITs are invested in physical properties, listed REITs or real estate-related stocks can be held in mutual funds. Their real estate exposure is generally lower than that in direct REIT holdings.
Must I liquidate all my investments in REITs at present?
Not necessarily. A partial shift allows you to retain some income-generating exposure while still benefiting from mutual fund diversification. The right mix would be based on your risk appetite and investment horizon.
What are the tax implications of REIT dividends versus mutual fund returns?
REIT dividends are typically taxed in the shareholder's hands, and there are specific holding period requirements for capital gains on selling units. Mutual funds, however, have more structured tax treatment based on whether they are debt or equity oriented. For individuals in higher tax brackets, mutual funds can offer better after-tax returns.
How can I balance my investment portfolio between REITs and mutual funds?
Balancing your portfolio involves considering your investment horizon, risk tolerance, and market expectations. Retaining some exposure to REITs for stable rental returns while adding mutual funds for diversification can help strike a balance between risk and potential returns.
Related News Articles
Unlocking the Potential of State-Owned Assets: BSNL and MTNL's Rs 1 Lakh Crore Land Bonanza
Property consultants and realty experts view the monetization of BSNL and MTNL assets as a significant opportunity
JM Financial Group Diversifies into Real Estate Funding
JM Financial Group is venturing into funding real estate projects through alternative investment funds and syndications, marking a shift in its investment strategy.
Unlocking the Secrets of Mumbai's Real Estate Market: A Guide to Buying a Home in India's Financial Capital
Discover the trends and costs of owning a home in Mumbai, India's most populous city, and learn why buyers and investors are flocking to the region's robust residential real estate sector.
Info Edge Sees 75% Surge in Q1 Profit, Driven by Naukri and 99acres Growth
Info Edge's Q1 profit jumps 75.6% to Rs 258.8 crore, driven by strong growth in recruitment and real estate businesses.
Uddhav Thackeray Accuses Amit Shah of Plotting to Break Opposition Ranks in Maharashtra
Uddhav Thackeray claims Amit Shah directed BJP leaders to split opposition and stop him and Sharad Pawar politically. Maharashtra assembly elections to be held by November 2024.
Mumbai Real Estate Market Soars with HOMETHON 2024, Unveiling Rs 10,000 Crore Inventory
The HOMETHON Property Expo 2024 in Mumbai highlights the city's dynamic real estate market with the launch of over 77 new projects, valued at Rs 10,000 crore.