ITAT Upholds Validity of Income Tax Return Filed 2 Seconds Late Due to Technical Glitches
The Pune Bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) has ruled in favor of Kumar Builders Project Pune Pvt. Ltd., a real estate development company, by upholding the validity of an income tax return filed 2 seconds late due to technical glitches on the Income Tax e-filing portal.
Income TaxReal EstateItatTax ReturnTechnical GlitchesReal Estate PuneJun 21, 2025
Kumar Builders Project Pune Pvt. Ltd. (assessee), a private limited company engaged in real estate development, faced scrutiny for Assessment Year (AY) 2019-20. The assessee filed the original return of income, declaring a loss of Rs. 1,22,14,57,394. The assessee claimed a TDS credit of Rs. 4,02,541, thereby seeking a refund of Rs. 4,02,541. The assessee filed a revised return on 06.03.2020, claiming a refund of Rs. 2,541 and a carry forward loss of Rs. 3,95,51,713.
The Central Processing Centre (CPC) disallowed the carry forward of the business loss, citing that the original return was filed belatedly, as the acknowledgment was generated at 00:00:02 hours on 01.11.2019, 2 seconds past the deadline of 31.10.2019.
Aggrieved by the CPC’s decision, the assessee appealed to the Additional/Joint Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) [Addl/JCIT(A)]. The Addl/JCIT(A) held that the return was filed in time, allowing the carry forward of the loss.
Aggrieved by the CPC’s decision, the Revenue filed an appeal before the ITAT. The counsel for the Revenue argued that the original return was filed after the statutory period and delayed by 2 seconds, and the CPC decision was fully justified.
The counsel for the assessee relied on precedents such as the Ahmedabad Bench’s decision in The Khedbrahma Taluka Primary Teachers Co-op. Credit Society Ltd. (delay of 4 minutes 42 seconds condoned) and the Mumbai Bench’s ruling in DCIT vs. M/s. Palava Dwellers Pvt. Ltd. (2-minute delay condoned). The counsel argued that a 2-second delay due to technical issues should not penalize the assessee.
The two-member bench, comprising R.K. Panda (Vice President) and Astha Chandra (Judicial Member), observed that the return was uploaded before midnight on 31.10.2019, but the acknowledgment was generated 2 seconds later due to technical glitches and portal rush. The Tribunal held that the 2-second delay was beyond the assessee’s control. The Tribunal affirmed the Addl/JCIT(A)’s order and held that there was no error in the order of Addl/JCIT(A).
The Tribunal directed the Assessing Officer to treat the return as filed in time under Section 139(1), allowing the carry forward of the business loss. The appeal of the Revenue was dismissed.
Frequently Asked Questions
What was the main issue in the case of Kumar Builders Project Pune Pvt. Ltd.?
The main issue was whether an income tax return filed 2 seconds late due to technical glitches on the Income Tax e-filing portal should be considered valid and treated as filed in time.
What was the decision of the Central Processing Centre (CPC) regarding the late filing?
The CPC disallowed the carry forward of the business loss, citing that the original return was filed belatedly, as the acknowledgment was generated 2 seconds past the deadline.
What precedent did the assessee's counsel rely on?
The assessee's counsel relied on precedents such as the Ahmedabad Bench’s decision in The Khedbrahma Taluka Primary Teachers Co-op. Credit Society Ltd. and the Mumbai Bench’s ruling in DCIT vs. M/s. Palava Dwellers Pvt. Ltd., where delays of 4 minutes 42 seconds and 2 minutes, respectively, were condoned.
What was the final decision of the ITAT?
The ITAT upheld the validity of the income tax return filed 2 seconds late, directing the Assessing Officer to treat the return as filed in time under Section 139(1), allowing the carry forward of the business loss.
What was the impact of the ITAT's decision on Kumar Builders Project Pune Pvt. Ltd.?
The ITAT's decision allowed Kumar Builders Project Pune Pvt. Ltd. to carry forward their business loss, which was previously disallowed by the CPC due to the 2-second delay in filing the return.
Related News Articles
India's Rise to Realty Prominence: A Billion-Dollar Boom
India is accelerating to become the real estate capital of Asia, with a total valuation of Rs 14.2 trillion among the top 100 realty companies.
Maharashtra Cabinet Renames Pune Airport After Sant Tukaram Maharaj
The Maharashtra Cabinet has approved a proposal to rename Pune airport after the 17th-century Warkari saint and poet, Sant Tukaram Maharaj.
The Downfall of Real Estate Moguls: Alexander Brothers Arrested in Miami
In a shocking turn of events, the renowned real estate moguls, the Alexander Brothers, were recently arrested in Miami. This news has sent ripples through the business community, leaving many to wonder what led to their downfall.
Luxury Homes, Toxic Air: The Urban Pollution Paradox in India
Nithin Kamath, a prominent real estate analyst, highlights the growing concern of urban pollution in major Indian cities like Delhi, Mumbai, and Bengaluru. Despite seeing a surge in luxury real estate, these cities struggle with alarming levels of air pol
Tragic Incident: Two Workers Killed, One Injured as Slab Collapses in Chikhla Mines
A devastating slab collapse in the Chikhla mines of Manganese Ore (India) has resulted in the death of two workers and left one injured. The incident has raised serious concerns about safety protocols in the mining industry.
Women Home Buyers Witness 14% Surge in 2024: Report
A recent report by Square Yards, titled 'Key Holders of Change - Women Driving Real Estate Growth and Transformation,' reveals a significant 14% increase in women homebuyers in 2024.