MahaREAT Finds MahaRERA's Dismissal of Homebuyer's Complaint Incorrect, Orders Refund of ₹4.5 Lakh
Maharashtra Real Estate Appellate Tribunal (MahaREAT) has set aside the order of Maharashtra Real Estate Regulatory Authority (MahaRERA) and directed the builder to refund ₹4.5 lakh to the homebuyer.
Maharashtra Real Estate Appellate TribunalMahareraHomebuyerComplaintRefundCompensationReal EstateSep 09, 2024
The homebuyer had booked a flat in the builder's project named Kanakia Miami situated at Mahim, on 28th March 2017, and executed and registered the agreement for sale on 28th June 2017 for a total consideration of ₹5,38,78,880/-. However, even after paying the full consideration to the builder, the complainant did not receive possession of the flat on time.
According to Clause 9(i) of the agreement for sale, the delivery of possession of the flat by the builder was supposed to be completed on or before 30th September 2018. The homebuyer filed a complaint before MahaRERA seeking a refund, compensation for the delay in delivery, and compensation for the deficit in carpet area.
MahaRERA, in its order dated 24th May 2021, held that the homebuyer cannot be permitted to agitate his claims as allottees at this belated stage and dismissed the complaint by holding it non-maintainable.
Aggrieved by the MahaRERA order, the homebuyer filed an appeal before the Tribunal seeking to set aside the order, a refund for the excess money taken by the builder, and interest for the delay in handing over the possession.
On the issue of maintainability, the Tribunal referred to Section 31 of the RERA, 2016, which stipulates that for a complaint to be valid, the Homebuyer must be aggrieved by violations of the Act, and the complaint must be against a builder, homebuyer, or real estate agent. Since both conditions were met in this case, the Tribunal held that MahaRERA had incorrectly dismissed the homebuyer's complaint as not maintainable.
The Tribunal also referred to clause 5(xvi) of the agreement for sale, which stipulated that – “A fee of ₹9,00,000 is payable to Kanakia Spaces Realty Private Limited by the sellers and purchasers in equal proportions for issuing the NOC and noting the lien in favor of the purchasers. Since no society has been formed yet, no transfer fees are payable to the society”.
The Tribunal determined that the builder cannot claim transfer fees for issuing the NOC as per the agreement. The homebuyer, along with other purchasers, were required to pay ₹9,00,000, as specified in the agreement. However, the Tribunal directed that only half of this amount, which is ₹4,50,000, should be refunded.
On the issue of the deficit in the carpet area, the Tribunal held that the homebuyer failed to provide convincing evidence regarding the alleged deficit. Therefore, the homebuyer is not entitled to a refund for the claimed shortfall in the carpet area.
On the issue of compensation, the Tribunal held that homebuyer is entitled to homebuyer interest at the prescribed rate for each month of delay until the possession of the flat is handed over. However, since the homebuyer have already settled for a rebate of ₹7,50,000, they are not entitled to additional interest for the delay in possession or to any further compensation.
Case – Mr. Jaikishan Udhav Lakhwani & anr Versus M/s. Kanakia Spaces Realty Private Limited
Citation - APPEAL NO. AT006000000053230
Frequently Asked Questions
What was the issue in the case?
The homebuyer had not received possession of the flat on time and had filed a complaint before MahaRERA seeking a refund, compensation for the delay in delivery, and compensation for the deficit in carpet area.
What was the order of MahaRERA?
MahaRERA held that the homebuyer cannot be permitted to agitate his claims as allottees at this belated stage and dismissed the complaint by holding it non-maintainable.
What was the decision of the Tribunal?
The Tribunal set aside the order of MahaRERA and directed the builder to refund ₹4.5 lakh to the homebuyer.
What was the reason for the refund?
The Tribunal determined that the builder cannot claim transfer fees for issuing the NOC as per the agreement and directed that only half of the amount, which is ₹4,50,000, should be refunded.
Was the homebuyer entitled to compensation?
The Tribunal held that homebuyer is entitled to homebuyer interest at the prescribed rate for each month of delay until the possession of the flat is handed over, but since the homebuyer have already settled for a rebate of ₹7,50,000, they are not entitled to additional interest for the delay in possession or to any further compensation.
Related News Articles
Real Estate Sector Grapples with Indexation Benefit Removal
The real estate sector is reeling from the removal of the indexation benefit for property sales, with industry players divided on its impact.
India's Real Estate Sector Sees a Slump in Housing Sales and New Launches
India's real estate sector has witnessed a decline in housing sales and new launches in the top nine cities between July and September, according to PropEquity.
Dream Works Realty Launches 'Realty Entrepreneurship Launchpad' in Pune
Pune, 10th October 2024: Dream Works Realty (DWR), a trusted and prominent real estate investment advisory, hosted a remarkable event at Pune’s Sheraton Grand Hotel to introduce its latest initiative, the Realty Entrepreneurship Launchpad. The initiative
Understanding FII Selling: Anand Rathi Wealth’s Feroze Azeez Shares Insights
Feroze Azeez from Anand Rathi Wealth provides a detailed analysis of how investors should interpret the Foreign Institutional Investors (FII) selling in the market. Discover key factors and strategies to navigate this trend.
Indian Stock Market Faces Sharp Decline as Various Sectors Take a Hit
The Indian stock market witnessed a significant plunge of over 1% today, driven by mixed economic cues. Key sectors such as real estate, public sector banks, metals, auto, and pharma experienced substantial declines, with the real estate sector being the
Rising Stars: Nagpur, Jaipur, and Lucknow Lead Real Estate Growth in India
These cities offer significant investment opportunities in the real estate sector, driven by robust infrastructure and demographic growth.