Operation Sindoor: The Reality Behind the Political Rhetoric
The recent Operation Sindoor and the subsequent remarks by Madhya Pradesh minister Kunwar Vijay Shah have brought to light the stark contrast between the Indian government's secular facade and the underlying communal tensions. This article explores the implications of these events on women's rights and national security.
Operation SindoorCommunal TensionsWomens RightsOnline AbusePolitical RhetoricReal Estate NewsMay 18, 2025
However, within a week, this carefully crafted projection began to unravel. Referring to Qureshi without naming her, Madhya Pradesh minister and Bharatiya Janata Party leader Kunwar Vijay Shah said, “Jinhone hamare betiyon ke sindoor uchala… humne unhi ki behen ko hamare jahaj mein bhej kar aise ki taisi karvai.” The ones who wiped off the sindoor of our sisters, Modi ji sent their own sister in our plane to teach them a lesson.
“You widowed our sisters,” he continued, rhetorically addressing the terrorists, “so we sent your sister to strip and humiliate you.” Shah’s crass and communal remarks drew outrage, criticism, and an FIR. The apology that followed was just as revealing. “Sister Sofia has brought glory to India by rising above caste and religion,” Shah told The Indian Express. “She is more respected than our own sister.”
Not only did the Madhya Pradesh minister perceive an accomplished and senior military officer as the “sister” of Pakistani terrorists merely because of her religious identity, but when criticized, his only resort was paternalism – that he respected the woman officer more than his own sister. This paternalism isn’t limited to Shah. In his speech on May 12, Prime Minister Narendra Modi said Operation Sindoor – code-named after the vermillion mark that is a symbol of marriage for Hindu women – represents the emotions of Indians.
“I dedicate Operation Sindoor to every mother, sister, and daughter,” he said. Now every terrorist knows the consequences of “removing the sindoor from the foreheads of our mothers and daughters,” he added. In the ideological framework of the Hindu Right, only some women are seen as worth protecting or celebrating: the behen who lost her sindoor and the behen who avenged the sindoor. Not the women who dare express opinions different from the establishment narrative.
Online abuse against women is rampant across India’s internet. This fortnight, the targets included the daughter of Foreign Secretary Vikram Misri and Himanshi Narwal, the widow of Naval officer Vinay Narwal, who was shot dead in the Pahalgam attack. War-mongers, disappointed at the announcement of a ceasefire, directed their ire at the foreign secretary by picking on his daughter Didon for writing an article in independent news outlet The Wire and for apparently providing legal assistance to Rohingya refugees in Myanmar. Even as diplomats, Opposition politicians, and associations representing the Indian civil and police services came to Misri’s defense, the government was silent.
Himanshi Narwal, despite being a “sister who lost her sindoor,” was subjected to sexual trolling because she had called for communal harmony and peace. The National Women’s Commission was sufficiently troubled by the online hate to issue a statement, but no concrete action was taken. In contrast, the Haryana Women’s Commission has summoned Ashoka University professor Ali Khan Mahmudabad for a Facebook post pointing out the irony of Hindutva commentators praising Qureshi while Indian Muslims face mob lynchings, demolitions, and persecution for their religious identity.
Two things are evident. First, the official silence on Misri and Narwal sends the disturbing message that the trolling and online abuse come with tacit approval. This covert sanction allows online mobs to police the narrative by viciously attacking detractors and critics. Second, it is once again apparent that the ruling party invokes gender and women solely to further its narrative. Ideologically, Hindutva is intolerant of the religious pluralism that was put on display at the May 7 press conference. It was bound to come apart.
Thirty years ago, scholar Amrita Basu had coined the term “feminism inverted” based on her research on women’s political activism in the Ram Janmabhoomi movement. Basu contended that the BJP was accommodating of women and even tolerated a vocabulary of women’s empowerment – as long as this served its “electorally driven communal strategy.” The events of the past two weeks have confirmed this.
Frequently Asked Questions
What was Operation Sindoor?
Operation Sindoor was a military operation conducted by India in response to terrorist attacks. It was named after the vermillion mark that is a symbol of marriage for Hindu women, symbolizing the protection of Indian women and families.
Who is Colonel Sofiya Qureshi?
Colonel Sofiya Qureshi is a Muslim woman military officer in the Indian Army who was fielded by the government to brief the press about the strikes carried out in Pakistan and Pakistan-occupied Kashmir.
What controversial remarks did Kunwar Vijay Shah make?
Kunwar Vijay Shah, a Madhya Pradesh minister, made communal and crass remarks about Colonel Sofiya Qureshi, suggesting that she was sent to strip and humiliate Pakistani terrorists because they had widowed Indian women.
How did Prime Minister Narendra Modi address the issue of Operation Sindoor?
Prime Minister Narendra Modi dedicated Operation Sindoor to every mother, sister, and daughter, emphasizing the emotional significance of the operation and the protection of Indian women.
What is the term 'feminism inverted' and who coined it?
The term 'feminism inverted' was coined by scholar Amrita Basu to describe how the BJP accommodates women and uses a vocabulary of women’s empowerment to further its communal and electoral strategies, while being intolerant of religious pluralism.
Related News Articles
Unlocking $48 Billion in Indian Office Space: The Rise of Fractional Ownership
India's fractional ownership market is expected to exceed $5 billion by 2030
Budget 2024: Reviving Affordable Housing - A Sector in Crisis
The real estate sector is seeking 'high-impact' measures to revive affordable housing, including special schemes, tax breaks, and revised pricing definitions.
Can Urbanization and Nature Coexist? A New Vision for Cities
As cities expand, natural spaces are dwindling. But is it possible to create a symbiosis between urbanization and nature? We explore the possibilities.
Market Sentiment Remains Robust Amidst Fresh IPOs: Anand Tandon
Anand Tandon shares his insights on the current market sentiment, IPOs, and sectors to watch out for.
MahaRERA Orders Developers to Refund Buyers Amid Complaints Over Pending Home Sales
The Maharashtra Real Estate Regulatory Authority (MahaRERA) has taken action against developers in Pune, a region heavily affected by pending home sales. MahaRERA has ordered developers to refund buyers to address the growing complaints.
Tayal Corp: Pioneering Architectural Excellence in Pune's Real Estate Market
Led by Ar. Sumit Tayal, Tayal Corp. is not just another real estate developer; it is a collective of thinkers, visionaries, and problem-solvers. Discover how this innovative company is transforming the landscape of Pune's real estate industry.