Skip to content
Search IGR records

Real Estate Mumbai

Redevelopment in Mumbai: Balancing Greed and Caution

By GeoSquare News Desk · Published 2026-01-21

In the ongoing redevelopment frenzy, homeowners must ensure greed doesn’t trump caution.

A friend’s building in Bandra is aiming to go for redevelopment. He told me, “members are expecting 120 per cent to 150 per cent extra area from the builder who comes in.” Effectively, an apartment owner with a 1,000 square feet home in the old building wants a 2,200-2,500 square feet home in the new building. This is no uncommon demand. It is widespread, shortsighted, and dangerous.

Welcome to, arguably, the peak of the frenzy in Mumbai redevelopment. Greed is high, but the greedy ones here are not the menacing builders; they are the housing societies. Redevelopment is not being viewed as an upgrade from a smaller to a bigger home. Instead, it is being seen as a jackpot opportunity for wealth creation that can take care of two generations. It’s hard to blame them. They have heard enough cases of that scenario to elevate their own expectations. And builders are partly to blame for this.

In the past three years, builders have been on a spree, undertaking redevelopment projects with low caution and high optimism. This has meant giving landowners offers that would be unimaginable in a routine business environment. Two factors drove them to do this. The first: The government allowing greater Floor Space Index (FSI). This allowed builders to construct more apartments or area. Earlier, an eight-storey building would have become 16 storeys after redevelopment. With the government raising FSI, now a builder can construct 23 storeys. That means he has more apartments to sell. That also means that he can give more area to existing apartment owners to win the bid for redevelopment.

The second factor: Stock markets. It may sound silly, but there was a phase until recently where stock prices of a builder would go up on the sheer announcement of the builder acquiring a project. That created an incentive structure where listed builders would give lucrative offers in redevelopment – even if it meant no profitability or negligible profitability in executing the project.

On their part, most society owners have viewed redevelopment with an excitement that resembles a kid in a toy store. Battles in selecting the builder have been largely on the basis of Corpus + Rent + Extra Area. Memories are short, and many have forgotten the consequences of poor selection of the builder that have driven residents to tragedy. Residents prefer to have their hope in a dream rather than believe in a likely reality. Greed has trumped caution.

The right way to approach redevelopment is to first remember: This is not a jackpot, and your building is not a casino. You do not need the “best” deal. There is a direct correlation between builders who offer the “best deal” and projects that later get stalled. Thereafter, impose conditions that provide an edge to skilled builders with a track record. Remember, every “brand” is not skilled, and every skilled player is not a brand. Within these builders, impose conditions that make skilled players with money come to the top of the selection pit.

Most redevelopment projects get launched with limited capital and a hope that quick purchases by new home buyers will then fund the project. In a competitive environment like it is now, where a buyer has several choices, that is an almost impossible scenario for 95 per cent of the projects. With that in mind, the capital of the builder will play a critical role in moving the project forward. The alternative is a capital-starved builder who slows down construction, which is often a precursor to a stalled project.

After all these filters are implemented, the lesser important factors like Corpus + Transit Rent + Extra Area should be considered. The builder selection should be the biggest factor in redevelopment, while the others are healthy enablers. Do it right. Control the greed. And redevelopment can be the guide to a wealthy life.

Related articles

Real Estate Mumbai news