Ultra-Safe Commercial Real Estate Debt Market Sees Unprecedented Losses

Defaults on high-quality properties are sparking losses for bond investors, a rare phenomenon in the commercial mortgage-backed securities market.

Commercial Real EstateDebt MarketCmbsBond InvestorsMortgage Backed SecuritiesReal EstateJul 17, 2024

Ultra-Safe Commercial Real Estate Debt Market Sees Unprecedented Losses
Real Estate:The commercial real estate sector is experiencing unprecedented losses, even in the ultra-safe corner of the market. Single-asset, single-borrower commercial mortgage-backed securities (CMBS), typically regarded as safe havens by bond investors, are seeing defaults and losses. According to the Commercial Real Estate Finance Council, the percentage of these bonds in or approaching default has climbed to 8.7% so far in 2024, about three times the default rate recorded two years ago.

This unexpected trend may surprise investors, as single-asset CMBS bonds are often rated triple-A by top rating agencies, with safety often seen on par with US Treasury bonds. However, debt holders of a high-profile AAA-rated building in midtown Manhattan lost more than 25% of their original investment after selling the bonds at a hefty discount, a first since the Great Financial Crisis.

The wave of debt coming due in the commercial real estate sector could further exacerbate the problem. Of the $260 billion of single-asset, single-borrower debt outstanding, $35 billion is approaching maturity this year, followed by $154 billion of maturing debt over the next three years. This could lead to a murky future for commercial real estate, where investors have been watching for signs of trouble since the pandemic.

Work-from-home trends have pushed office vacancy rates to the highest level recorded, according to Moody's data. Interest rates, meanwhile, look poised to stay higher for longer, potentially sparking more distress as $1 trillion of debt in the overall commercial real estate sector approaches maturity by the end of this year. This cocktail of high rates and anemic demand could result in more defaults and forced selling by property owners at heavy discounts.

Office buildings are a particular sore spot, with about $52 billion, or a third of all office loans packaged into bonds, in or approaching default in March. Commercial real estate foreclosures broadly spiked 117% year-over-year in the first quarter, according to data from property analytics firm ATTOM.

Frequently Asked Questions

What type of bonds are typically seen as safe havens by bond investors?

Single-asset, single-borrower commercial mortgage-backed securities (CMBS)

What is the default rate for single-asset, single-borrower bonds?

8.7% so far in 2024, about three times the default rate recorded two years ago

How much debt is approaching maturity in the commercial real estate sector?

$35 billion this year, followed by $154 billion over the next three years

What is the impact of work-from-home trends on office vacancy rates?

Office vacancy rates have been pushed to the highest level recorded

How much has commercial real estate foreclosures increased year-over-year?

117% in the first quarter

Related News Articles

India's NCLT Sets New Benchmark with 269 Resolution Plans Approved in FY24
Real Estate Mumbai

India's NCLT Sets New Benchmark with 269 Resolution Plans Approved in FY24

In a significant development, the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) has approved a record 269 resolution plans in the fiscal year 2023-24, marking a major milestone in the country's efforts to tackle corporate insolvency.

August 3, 2024
Read Article
HOMETHON Property Expo 2024 Embraces Sustainability
Real Estate Mumbai

HOMETHON Property Expo 2024 Embraces Sustainability

Mumbai, Maharashtra, India - The National Real Estate Development Council (NAREDCO) is proud to present the third edition of India's premier property expo, HOMETHON, with a focus on sustainable living.

October 1, 2024
Read Article
Mumbai's Western Seafront: Challenges and Controversies in Developing an Entertainment Hub
Real Estate

Mumbai's Western Seafront: Challenges and Controversies in Developing an Entertainment Hub

The ambitious plan to transform Mumbai’s western sea fronts into an entertainment hub faces significant challenges from real estate developers, slum rehabilitation concerns, and environmental objections over mangrove destruction.

October 27, 2024
Read Article
Mumbai's Property Registrations Show 3% Year-on-Year Growth in November
Real Estate Mumbai

Mumbai's Property Registrations Show 3% Year-on-Year Growth in November

Despite a 27% month-on-month dip, Mumbai's property registrations recorded a 3% increase year-on-year in November, with stamp duty collections rising by 28%, according to IGR data.

November 30, 2024
Read Article
Oberoi Realty: Pioneering Modern Luxury Homeownership in Mumbai
Real Estate Mumbai

Oberoi Realty: Pioneering Modern Luxury Homeownership in Mumbai

Oberoi Realty, a leading player in the luxury real estate sector, is setting new standards by anticipating the needs of modern homeowners in Mumbai. With a focus on sustainability, technology, and community, the company is redefining the luxury living exp

March 10, 2025
Read Article
Pune's Suburbs Emerge as Prime Real Estate Destinations
Real Estate Pune

Pune's Suburbs Emerge as Prime Real Estate Destinations

Pune's real estate market is witnessing a significant shift as the city's suburbs are becoming increasingly attractive for homebuyers and investors. Once considered remote, these areas are now bustling with development and offer a range of amenities and i

March 13, 2025
Read Article