West Bengal Tribunal Dismisses Landowners' Complaint Against Developer Over Simultaneous Proceedings
The West Bengal Real Estate Appellate Tribunal has dismissed a complaint by landowners against developer Ashok Dutta, stating that identical claims cannot be pursued in multiple legal forums simultaneously.
Real EstateLegal ProceedingsWest BengalLandownersDeveloperReal Estate NewsSep 13, 2025
The case arose from a development agreement signed on 17 August 2015 between Ashok Dutta and landowners, including Champak Bhattacharjee and four others, for a property at 10 Italgacha Road, Dum Dum, North 24 Parganas. The agreement involved the construction of three buildings.
Disputes among co-owners over flat allocation caused delays and obstructions in the development process. Despite the completion of construction, unresolved issues led the complainants to file a case with the State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, West Bengal, earlier this year.
At the same time, they filed a similar complaint with the West Bengal Real Estate Regulatory Authority, seeking identical remedies.
Ashok Dutta challenged the maintainability of the complaint before the Regulatory Authority, arguing that simultaneous proceedings were not allowed. His application was initially rejected on 14 May 2025. Upon appeal, the Appellate Tribunal, led by Justice (retd) Rabindra Nath Samanta as chairman and administrative member Subrat Mukherjee, reviewed the facts and relevant Supreme Court precedents.
The Tribunal ruled that the complainants cannot pursue the same cause of action in both the Consumer Commission and the Regulatory Authority simultaneously. It set aside the Regulatory Authority's order and dismissed the complaint. However, it allowed the complainants to withdraw their case from the Consumer Commission and refile it with the Regulatory Authority if they choose, in accordance with the law.
Frequently Asked Questions
What was the main reason for the dismissal of the landowners' complaint?
The main reason for the dismissal was that identical claims cannot be pursued in multiple legal forums simultaneously.
Who is Ashok Dutta and what is his role in this case?
Ashok Dutta is the proprietor of Sreeram Enterprise and was involved in a development agreement with the landowners for a property in North 24 Parganas.
What was the development agreement about?
The development agreement, signed on 17 August 2015, involved the construction of three buildings on a property at 10 Italgacha Road, Dum Dum, North 24 Parganas.
What was the outcome of the Appellate Tribunal's review?
The Appellate Tribunal ruled that the complainants cannot pursue the same cause of action in both the Consumer Commission and the Regulatory Authority simultaneously, setting aside the Regulatory Authority's order and dismissing the complaint.
What options do the landowners have after the dismissal?
The landowners can withdraw their case from the Consumer Commission and refile it with the Regulatory Authority if they choose to do so, in accordance with the law.
Related News Articles
Pune's Commercial Real Estate Boom: A Thriving Metropolis in 2024
Pune's commercial real estate sector is thriving in 2024
Emerging Real Estate Opportunities: Senior Living and Kid-Centric Homes
The Indian real estate sector is witnessing a shift towards specialized housing, particularly in senior living and kid-centric spaces. These segments are not just about living; they are about enhancing the quality of life for specific age groups.
Mumbai Real Estate Agents Brutally Assaulted by Mistaken Identity
In a shocking incident in Mumbai, four real estate agents were stripped and given electric shocks by three individuals who mistook them for BMC informants. The brutal assault occurred after the agents were taking photos of an under-construction site in An
Boosting Real Estate Demand in Emerging Cities: A Framework for Global Capability Centres
Given India's rising economic influence, this move is expected to fuel office space demand in major metros like Bengaluru, Mumbai, Hyderabad, and Pune.
India's Office Leasing Reaches New High at 81.7 MSF in 2024, IT/ITES Sectors Drive Demand
India's office leasing market set a new record in 2024, with 81.7 million square feet (MSF) of space leased. The IT and ITES sectors are leading the demand, driving the robust growth.
Why Ford Motor, Bank of America, and Wells Fargo Are Key Players in the Real Estate Market
Discover how these major corporations, traditionally not associated with real estate, have become significant players in the property market due to their extensive property holdings and lending practices.