Why Buying a ₹3 Crore Home in India is a Poor Investment: Expert Breaks It Down
Wealth advisor Parag Aggarwal explains why buying a ₹3 crore home in India is more of a financial burden than an investment, with total costs over 15 years reaching ₹4.5 crore and offering weak returns compared to other asset classes.
Real EstateInvestmentFinancial AdviceAsset AllocationPropertyReal Estate NewsJun 04, 2025
Aggarwal breaks down the real cost: over 15 years, the total outflow through EMIs and interest stretches far beyond the sticker price. “A ₹3 crore house doesn’t cost ₹3 crore,” he notes. “That’s what you will pay over 15 years…as EMIs and interest.”
More concerning, he argues, is what buyers get in return: modest appreciation of around 4–5% annually, plus an optional 2–3% in rental yields—far below the performance of other investment classes. Gold has averaged returns of ~11.6% over 15 years, while Indian equities have delivered ~13.7%.
“Real estate has been a laggard,” Aggarwal writes, noting that these returns don’t account for maintenance costs, property taxes, or the liquidity challenges of selling a home when needed.
Yet, despite these figures, homeownership remains a cultural expectation. “Renting means you’re not stable,” he says, citing common social pressures to buy property before marriage or as a marker of adulthood.
Aggarwal, who owns a home himself, is candid about his motivations. “My wife and I knew it was an emotional decision, NOT a financial one,” he writes. They prioritized peace of mind over investment logic, paying off their home loan early—not for returns, but for psychological comfort.
For his clients, however, he urges caution. He advises against early-stage home buying, particularly when it risks skewing asset allocation. “Very, very carefully,” he emphasizes.
Real estate, he argues, should come late in the investment journey, once equities, gold, and other liquid assets are well-established. “Else Real Estate will end up being 70–80% of your portfolio,” he warns.
His conclusion is clear: a house you live in isn’t an investment. “Remember—if you are staying in it—your house is an item of ‘consumption’, not an investment.”
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the total cost of a ₹3 crore home over 15 years?
The total cost of a ₹3 crore home over 15 years, including EMIs and interest, is approximately ₹4.5 crore.
What are the typical returns on real estate compared to other investments?
Real estate typically offers modest appreciation of around 4–5% annually and optional 2–3% in rental yields, which is far below the performance of other investment classes like gold (11.6%) and Indian equities (13.7%).
Why is homeownership still a cultural expectation in India?
Homeownership remains a cultural expectation in India due to social pressures, such as the belief that renting means instability and the expectation to own a property before marriage or as a marker of adulthood.
What is Parag Aggarwal's personal stance on homeownership?
Parag Aggarwal, who owns a home himself, acknowledges that his decision was an emotional one for peace of mind, not a financial investment.
When should real estate be considered in an investment portfolio?
According to Aggarwal, real estate should be considered late in the investment journey, after establishing a strong portfolio of equities, gold, and other liquid assets.
Related News Articles
IAS Probationer Puja Khedkar's Luxury Car Seized by Pune Traffic Police over Multiple Violations
The Pune Traffic Police seized the luxury car used by trainee IAS Officer Puja Khedkar over alleged misuse of power, multiple traffic violations, and unauthorized use of beacon and VIP number plate.
India's Real Estate Market Poised for Explosive Growth, Set to Reach $10 Trillion by 2047
The Indian real estate market is expected to play a crucial role in the country's economic growth, with a projected value of $10 trillion by 2047.
Delhi-NCR Ranks 6th in Asia Pacific for Office Rent, Clocking Rs 340 per Sq Ft Monthly
According to real estate consultant Knight Frank's latest Asia-Pacific Prime Office Rental Index for Q3 2024, Delhi-NCR has secured the 6th position in terms of office rent, with a monthly rate of Rs 340 per square foot.
Real Estate Developers Petition Maharashtra Government for Stamp Duty Reduction and Incentives
NAREDCO Maharashtra, a prominent real estate developer body, met with Maharashtra's Revenue Minister Chandrashekhar Bawankule to submit a series of proposals aimed at boosting the real estate sector through reduced stamp duties and other incentives.
Luxury Real Estate Market Thrives Amid High Net Worth Individuals and Capital Market Gains
Since the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, the real estate sector has experienced a significant surge in demand for luxury properties, largely driven by high net worth individuals (HNIs) and robust capital market returns.
Shekhar G Patel Elected President of CREDAI for 2025-27: A New Era for Real Estate Development
Shekhar G Patel, a prominent real estate developer, has been elected as the President of CREDAI for the term 2025-27, succeeding Boman Irani of Keystone Realtors Ltd. This new leadership is expected to bring fresh perspectives and innovative solutions to the real estate industry.