Why India Should Allow Chinese FDI: Sanjeev Sanyal
Economist Sanjeev Sanyal bats for foreign direct investment from China, citing benefits for India's exports and manufacturing sector.
Sanjeev SanyalChinese FdiEconomic Survey 202324Indiachina RelationsFdi PolicyReal EstateOct 02, 2024
China is the cheapest source of many things that India wants to do, and the US is unable to get rid of China, Sanyal said in an interview. Almost no country can do without them, and we already are trading. So the question is - if we are going to import these parts etc for, say the iPhone or whatever - why not allow them to manufacture in India, and why force them to remain in China or to invest in some other country from where we will import it...why not let them do it here?
Sanyal pointed out that this is not an unusual situation and has happened in the past. China's own industrialisation happened with investments from Japan, with whom they had fairly tricky relations. If you think we have frictions between us and China, given the history of Japan and China - you can imagine how rocky that is. If we go all the way back, the industrialisation of Germany was done with British capital. The industrialisation of Japan was done with American capital.
So, geopolitical rival countries with friction against each other have throughout history traded and received investment from them, he said. You can be both a collaborator and a competitor at the same time. This is the way the world works. The dramatic rise of China...and now becoming a cutting edge country has been driven by capital from Japan and the US.
Endorsing the survey's pitch, Sanyal said it was not unusual for countries to accept foreign capital. There is obviously certain areas where the government will have some concerns, he said. You don't want Huawei, for example, to run your telecommunication system...everyone knows concerns about them. You may not want Chinese companies to dominate our procurement system. But there are large areas where it is anyway pointless avoiding them and there are many areas they will bring talent.
They are at the cutting edge of technology in many areas. They will create jobs here and also provide capital. Because there are many Chinese entrepreneurs who want to leave China - why don't we become a beneficiary of that process? he said, but added that New Delhi's security concerns are also real.
I am of the view that we need to find that sensible balance. In the last few months, we have seen several electronic related companies being given approval even in the existing system. So even the existing system is speeding things up a bit, he said.
The bilateral relations between India and China have strained since June 2020 when the Chinese military made a unilateral move along the border in Eastern Ladakh. Following these tensions, India restricted direct investment from China, and other countries sharing land borders. New Delhi also banned over 200 Chinese mobile apps such as Tiktok, Wechat, and Alibaba’s UC browser. It also rejected a major investment proposal from EV maker BYD.
However, the survey batted for direct investment from China which it said can boost India's exports to the US, similar to how East Asian economies did in the past. Choosing FDI as a strategy to benefit from the China plus one approach appears more advantageous than relying on trade, the survey noted. This is because China is India's top import partner, and the trade deficit with China has been growing.
As the US and Europe shift their immediate sourcing away from China, it is more effective to have Chinese companies invest in India and then export the products to these markets rather than importing from China, adding minimal value, and then re-exporting them, the survey said.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why does Sanjeev Sanyal support Chinese FDI in India?
Sanyal argues that China is already India's largest source of imports, and it is pointless to wish them away. He believes that allowing Chinese companies to manufacture in India will create jobs and provide capital, while also reducing India's dependence on imports from China.
What are the security concerns related to Chinese FDI in India?
Sanyal acknowledges that New Delhi's security concerns are real, particularly with regards to companies like Huawei, which have been flagged for their potential ties to the Chinese government.
How can Chinese FDI benefit India's exports?
The Economic Survey 2023-24 suggests that Chinese FDI can boost India's exports to the US, similar to how East Asian economies did in the past. By allowing Chinese companies to invest in India and manufacture products for export, India can reduce its trade deficit with China and increase its exports to other countries.
What is the current status of India-China relations?
The bilateral relations between India and China have strained since June 2020, when the Chinese military made a unilateral move along the border in Eastern Ladakh. India has since restricted direct investment from China and banned several Chinese mobile apps.
What is the 'China plus one' approach mentioned in the Economic Survey?
The 'China plus one' approach refers to the strategy of diversifying supply chains away from China, while still maintaining economic ties with the country. The Economic Survey suggests that this approach can be beneficial for India, as it can attract foreign investment and boost exports to other countries.
Related News Articles
I-T Department Clarifies Real Estate LTCG Calculations: A Guide for Property Owners
This update is crucial for property owners and investors seeking to understand the tax implications of selling real estate assets.
Suraj Estate to Raise ₹500 Crore via Preferential Issue of Shares and Warrants
Suraj Estate Developers Ltd. is set to raise up to ₹500 crore through a preferential issue of shares and warrants to eligible shareholders. The company's board has approved the fundraise, which will see shares issued to notable names including Vanaja Sund
Is the Commercial Real Estate Boom a Sustainable Trend or a Bubble?
Explore the current state of the commercial real estate market in major cities like Mumbai, Delhi, and Pune, and find out whether this boom is a long-term trend or a speculative bubble.
Top Tier-2 Cities Emerge as Real Estate Powerhouses
Property values in top tier-2 cities are now on par with major metropolitan areas like Gurgaon, Mumbai, and Bangalore. The growth of educational institutions is also playing a significant role in attracting more residents and investors to these burgeoning
Roadway Solutions Secures Rs 47 Billion Loan for Major MSRDC Projects
In a significant development, Roadway Solutions, a leading infrastructure development company, has secured a Rs 47 billion Line of Advance (LOA) from leading financial institutions to fund major projects for the Maharashtra State Road Development Corporat
Capex Trends in India: Slower Pace of Investment in Q3
The construction and real estate sectors are facing a significant decline in new project announcements, while manufacturing and other sectors show mixed performance.