Mumbai Residents Raise Red Flags Over Managing Committee-Builder Nexus in Redevelopment Deals
Mumbai's real estate industry is booming, but the role of managing committees in housing societies has come under scrutiny. Residents are concerned about potential conflicts of interest and underhand deals between committee members and builders.
MumbaiReal EstateRedevelopmentManaging CommitteeBuilderReal Estate MumbaiAug 02, 2025
In a Vile Parle society, a woman member filed a case in the consumer court against the managing committee for allotting her a flat on a lower floor instead of a higher floor, which she claimed she was supposed to get. In Mumbai's real estate industry, redevelopment has become the most lucrative market not just for developers hunting for prime properties.
A lesser-known secret is the role of the all-powerful managing committees (MCs) of housing societies; these are small groups of people who initiate redevelopment, meet developers, and finally convince society members to select the best. TOI spoke to a cross-section of people in the redevelopment market, including builders, advocates, housing society members, architects, and activists, about the crucial role played by MCs and the influence they wield among competitive developers.
Advocate K K Ramani, who has many housing societies as his clients during redevelopment, said the MC has a lot to contribute and its members devote their time and effort. 'Someone has to make a decision, good or bad. It is a thankless job. They cannot satisfy everyone,' he said. Ramani believes residents are more aware of their rights and keep MCs on their toes, but people in the know told TOI that underhand benefits for MC members continue from builders and are of varied nature. Ramani said the MCs he deals with are dedicated people and do not short-change other members. 'It used to happen two decades ago when society members left everything to the MC to decide during redevelopment. Now, members are more aware of their rights,' he added.
However, people in the know told TOI that underhand benefits for MC members continue. 'Their chosen builder will give them preferential treatment like better amenities, more area than they are entitled to at a discounted price, or free interiors of the new flat. Or it could be giving an MC member his redeveloped flat on a higher, sea-facing side,' they said. A developer, who spoke to TOI on the condition that his identity not be revealed, said his experience with MCs was that '25% are genuine while 75% have vested interests.' 'Someone from the MC wants more area, others may demand money on the side,' he said. This developer also claimed that several 'project management consultants' (PMCs) appointed by MCs to help societies in the redevelopment process have become 'glorified brokers' and are 'super corrupt.'
'They knock out money from developers for selecting them for redevelopment,' he said. Another developer with a slew of redevelopment projects in the prime Bandra-Khar belt said some PMCs and MCs 'rig tenders' so that the project goes to a selected builder. 'These syndicates (nexus of PMC and MC) are known to get kickbacks ranging from Rs 5 crore to Rs 10 crore in prime localities. Redevelopment is their payday,' he said. This developer further said what surprises him is that most of these shady MC members come from a wealthy background.
Housing activist Chandrashekar Prabhu, who has been pushing for self-redevelopment, said some builders inflate numbers in feasibility reports for redevelopment. 'These builders spend huge sums to pay office bearers to select PMCs on their payrolls so that they can manipulate the feasibility reports to make it appear that the builders would hardly earn any profits in the redevelopment schemes. In return for convincing members to agree to a PMC, the architect, structural engineer, liaison consultant, other consultants, select managing committee members, and office bearers are paid off. Some builders offer upfront payment to office bearers to identify vulnerable families willing to sell their flats. Moreover, if all members can be convinced that the deal offered is the best, proactive office bearers will be given free flats in another project. For every decision that results in an increase of profits for the builder, there is a good share of the spoils for office bearers,' he said.
Advocate Vinod Sampat said the positive aspect of MCs is they protect the interests of society members. 'Many of these committees are experts in various fields and are knowledgeable. Most decisions are taken transparently,' he said. But Sampat said he has seen the dark side too, where an MC is hand-in-glove with the developer. 'The rotten ones will deliberately leave loopholes in development agreements so that income tax and GST liability falls on the members instead of the developer,' he said, adding that arbitration with the builder in case of a dispute will financially ruin the society.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the role of managing committees in housing societies during redevelopment?
Managing committees (MCs) in housing societies play a crucial role in initiating redevelopment, meeting developers, and convincing society members to select the best developer for the project.
What are some of the underhand benefits MC members might receive from builders?
MC members might receive preferential treatment, better amenities, more area at a discounted price, free interiors, or flats on higher, sea-facing floors.
How do project management consultants (PMCs) influence the redevelopment process?
PMCs appointed by MCs to help societies in the redevelopment process can become 'glorified brokers' and are known to be 'super corrupt,' often demanding money from developers for selecting them for redevelopment.
What are some of the unethical practices builders use to manipulate feasibility reports?
Builders may inflate numbers in feasibility reports and pay office bearers to select PMCs on their payrolls, manipulating the reports to make it appear that the builders would hardly earn any profits in the redevelopment schemes.
What are the potential risks for housing societies if MCs are hand-in-glove with developers?
If MCs are colluding with developers, they might deliberately leave loopholes in development agreements, leading to income tax and GST liability falling on the members instead of the developer, and arbitration with the builder in case of a dispute could financially ruin the society.
Related News Articles
Elevating Civil Aviation: Mohol's Pioneering Role in Pune
Discover how Mohol is driving growth in Pune's civil aviation sector, with insights from Hemant Rasne, former Mayor and BJP leader.
Budget 2024: A Boost to Sustainable Growth in Real Estate
The Union Budget 2024 focuses on MSMEs, employment, skilling, youth, and middle-class, with indirect benefits to the real estate sector through job creation, infrastructure, and urban redevelopment.
Dubai Real Estate Market Sets AED 141.9 Billion Quarterly Sales Record in Q3 2024
Dubai’s real estate market achieved a significant milestone in Q3 2024, with total sales reaching AED 141.9 billion, marking a new all-time high for a single quarter. This achievement surpassed the previous record of AED 124.07 billion set in Q2 2024, ref
Elan Group Gets a Boost with Rs 1200 Crore from Kotak Real Estate Fund
The investment will serve as growth capital, helping Elan Group cement its position in the thriving real estate market of Gurugram. This strategic move is expected to accelerate the company's expansion and development projects in the region.
Delhi-NCR: The Metro City Witnessing a Massive Surge in Housing Prices
The report suggests that the price appreciation in Delhi-NCR is attributed to rising demand for high-end properties. Read more to know the details.
Radisson Resort Khopoli Launches as a Luxurious Getaway Near Mumbai and Pune
Radisson Hotel Group has expanded its footprint in Maharashtra with the opening of Radisson Resort Khopoli, offering a premium retreat for travelers near Mumbai and Pune.