Supreme Court Ruling Reopens Environmental Clearances for 500 Real Estate Projects in Mumbai and Pune
A recent Supreme Court ruling has allowed state authorities to resume environmental impact assessments for around 500 real estate projects in the Mumbai Metropolitan Region (MMR) and Pune, resolving a long-standing legal ambiguity.
Supreme CourtReal EstateEnvironmental ClearanceMumbaiPuneReal Estate MumbaiAug 12, 2025
The Supreme Court last week stated that the State Environment Impact Assessment Authority (SEIAA), as well as the advisory State Expert Appraisal Committee (SEAC), will remain the 'competent authorities' to seek environmental clearance (EC) for Category B projects in the EIA notification of 2006, which includes buildings or township projects. All Category A projects must be assessed for an EC by the Union government, through the Union Ministry of Environment, Forests and Climate Change and its EAC.
It also ruled that the General Condition to the EIA notification of 2006, in which Category B projects with 20,000 square metres of built-up area are deemed to be Category A if they are located within 5 kilometres of an eco-sensitive zone, will not be applicable to real estate projects under Category B and will continue to be assessed for an EC at the state level only. The legal matter had held up the approval of such projects across India, including around 700 in Maharashtra alone, according to legal experts and real estate observers.
In 2014, the Union government clarified that the General Condition does not apply to real estate projects. That exemption was ended by the Kerala High Court in 2024, and the National Green Tribunal also sided with the Kerala HC regarding the '5 kilometre' clause. Following this, CREDAI-MCHI, the developers' advocacy group in the MMR, filed a writ petition in the Supreme Court to clarify the matter, with intervention from CREDAI National as well as Godrej Properties.
'This judgment is a direct result of CREDAI-MCHI’s proactive legal intervention to protect the interests of our members and the thousands of homebuyers impacted by stalled projects. We initiated this petition to bring clarity to an increasingly complex and ambiguous environmental clearance process, and we are grateful that the Hon’ble Supreme Court has upheld the role of SEIAA and SEAC as competent authorities,' said Domnic Romell, president, CREDAI-MCHI. The body noted that the ruling removes ambiguity around 70,000 housing units across the stalled projects, mainly in the affordable and mid-income categories.
Markets affected
Developers said that projects in a number of MMR areas were stalled as a result of the regulatory issues, due to much of Mumbai being located within a short distance from eco-sensitive zones such as mangroves, forests, or hills. Many were held up in areas such as Mulund and Thane, which adjoin the Thane creek mangroves and the saltpans along the eastern seaboard of the city. Some were also stuck in areas such as Borivali, Dahisar, and Goregaon due to these areas being located close to the Sanjay Gandhi National Park, as well as the Aarey Milk Colony forests.
'Prior to the ruling, projects in areas such as Mahim and Dadar, which are highly built-up and populated areas, were stalled due to the EC requirement from the Union government. In areas such as Mulund, Kanjurmarg, and Thane, especially in the Navi Mumbai to Thane corridor, some of the projects were stuck due to the mangroves nearby as well as the flamingo sanctuary near the Eastern Express Highway,' said a real estate observer based in Mumbai.
Legal experts said that the sheer volume of projects made the deemed Category A status of some real estate projects unviable, even if Union government clearance was needed. 'If the condition of Union government assessment for all deemed Category A real estate projects stood, more projects would have been stuck at the approvals process. The Union government also submitted to the court that it does not have the bandwidth to process the environmental clearances of hundreds of such projects at any given time,' Samit Shukla, partner, dispute resolution practice, Trilegal, told Moneycontrol. Trilegal represented CREDAI National and Godrej Properties in the matter. Shukla added that the judgment can clear over 1,000 cases nationally.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the significance of the Supreme Court's ruling on real estate projects in Mumbai and Pune?
The ruling allows state authorities to resume environmental impact assessments for Category B projects, resolving a long-standing legal ambiguity and potentially unlocking around 500 stalled real estate projects.
Which projects are categorized as Category B in the EIA notification of 2006?
Category B projects include buildings or township projects that require environmental clearance but are assessed at the state level, as opposed to Category A projects which are assessed by the Union government.
Why were real estate projects in Mumbai and Pune stalled?
Projects were stalled due to a legal ambiguity regarding the '5 kilometre' clause, which deemed Category B projects as Category A if located within 5 kilometres of an eco-sensitive zone, requiring Union government clearance.
How does the ruling affect homebuyers in Mumbai and Pune?
The ruling removes the ambiguity around 70,000 housing units across the stalled projects, primarily in the affordable and mid-income categories, potentially leading to faster project completion and delivery.
What was the role of CREDAI-MCHI in this legal battle?
CREDAI-MCHI, the developers' advocacy group in the MMR, filed a writ petition in the Supreme Court to clarify the environmental clearance process and protect the interests of developers and homebuyers.
Related News Articles
Stable Outlook for Real Estate in Key Cities This Fiscal
The mid to high-end housing segment is witnessing higher offtakes, particularly in the suburbs of Delhi NCR, Pune, Mumbai, and Chennai, as homebuyers seek more spacious and affordable options.
The Mysterious Death of Baba Siddique and the Rise of Lawrence Bishnoi in Telangana Politics
Baba Siddique was more than just a political figure; he had deep connections in Bollywood and the real estate sector in Mumbai. His untimely death has left many questions unanswered, while the rise of Lawrence Bishnoi in Telangana's political landscape ha
Sumit Woods Limited Reports 171% Surge in Consolidated PAT in Q2 FY25
Mumbai (Maharashtra) [India], November 16: Sumit Woods Limited, a leading player in the real estate sector, has reported a significant surge in its consolidated profit after tax (PAT) in the second quarter of the fiscal year 2025, marking a remarkable 171
Maharashtra to Finalise Executing Agency for Rs 150 Bn Corridor Project
The Maharashtra government is set to finalize the executing agency for the Rs 150 billion corridor project connecting Mumbai and Navi Mumbai. This initiative is aimed at enhancing the real estate and infrastructure development in the region.
Agarwal Holdings Snags Prestigious Juhu Land for Rs 455 Crore from Shapoorji Pallonji
Agarwal Holdings, a leading real estate player, has made a significant move in the Mumbai real estate market by acquiring a prime parcel of land in Juhu from the Shapoorji Pallonji Group for Rs 455 crore. This strategic acquisition underscores the growing
Vinhomes and Nomura Real Estate Group Sign Strategic Cooperation MoU
This partnership aims to leverage the strengths of both parties to provide the market with groundbreaking real estate products that meet international standards.