Supreme Court Upholds Church Trust's Preferential Right in Slum Land Acquisition
The Supreme Court of India has ruled in favor of the Basilica of Our Lady of the Mount, upholding the Church Trust's preferential right to redevelop a disputed area in Bandra, Mumbai. This decision strikes down the acquisition attempts by Saldanha Real Estate Pvt. Ltd.
Supreme CourtChurch TrustSlum RehabilitationReal EstateMumbaiReal Estate MumbaiAug 25, 2025
A portion of this land, long occupied by shacks, was declared a slum area in 1978. Over the years, the slum dwellers formed Shri Kadeshwari CHS Ltd. and entered into a redevelopment agreement with Saldanha Real Estate Pvt. Ltd. The Church Trust, however, had its own plans for a comprehensive redevelopment project that included the disputed land.
In 2021, when the Church Trust submitted its redevelopment proposal to the Slum Rehabilitation Authority (SRA), it was rejected on technical grounds. Saldanha Real Estate, which had already lodged its proposal, continued with the acquisition proceedings. The Bombay High Court, however, overturned the acquisition, recognizing the Church Trust's preferential right to redevelop the land. This led to an appeal by Saldanha Real Estate and other appellants to the Supreme Court.
Court Proceedings
The appellants, including Saldanha Real Estate Pvt. Ltd., Shri Kadeshwari CHS Ltd., and the SRA, argued that the Church Trust's redevelopment proposal was defective, late, and not in the proper format. They further claimed that the 2018 Amendment to the Slum Areas Act reversed the burden of action, requiring landowners to act within 120 days of a slum declaration. They also contended that the Trust's decades of inactivity justified the acquisition.
In response, the Church Trust asserted that its right to redevelop the land was not waived and that it had submitted its proposal in time. The Trust alleged that the SRA had colluded with Saldanha Real Estate, rejecting the Trust's proposal on technical grounds while accepting similar proposals from Saldanha. The Trust also argued that the acquisition was driven by malafide intentions, allowing Saldanha to exploit the land at undervalued rates.
Court’s Reasoning
The Supreme Court, in its judgment, referred to several precedents, including the Tarabai Nagar Co-Op. Housing Society case, which addressed the right of landowners to redevelop slum rehabilitation sites. The Court held that the 2018 Amendment did not weaken the preferential right of landowners; instead, it strengthened it by incorporating owners into the statutory framework. The Court noted that no valid notice was issued to the Church Trust, thereby preserving its preferential right.
The Court also found evidence of collusion between Saldanha Real Estate, Shri Kadeshwari CHS Ltd., and the SRA. The rejection of the Church Trust's proposal on technical grounds while accepting similar proposals from Saldanha indicated bias and malafide intentions. As a result, the Supreme Court upheld the decision of the Bombay High Court, declaring a significant portion of the acquisition illegal and tainted with malafide intentions.
The Court ordered that the Church Trust be given 120 days to present a proper redevelopment scheme, and the SRA and the State were mandated to process and accommodate this scheme within 60 days of its filing. The rights of the slum dwellers were to be protected in accordance with the existing undertakings with the Trust.
Conclusion
This decision by the Supreme Court reaffirms the priority rights of landowners in slum redevelopment projects, protecting them against opportunistic and collusive tendencies in the real estate industry. It ensures that the rights of landowners and the needs of slum dwellers are balanced, promoting fair and just urban development in Mumbai.
Frequently Asked Questions
What was the main issue in the dispute between the Church Trust and Saldanha Real Estate?
The main issue was the redevelopment rights of land at CTS No. B-960, Bandra, Mumbai. The Church Trust claimed its preferential right to redevelop the land, while Saldanha Real Estate sought to acquire and develop the land through the Slum Rehabilitation Authority.
What did the Supreme Court decide in this case?
The Supreme Court upheld the Church Trust's preferential right to redevelop the land, declaring a significant portion of the acquisition by Saldanha Real Estate illegal and tainted with malafide intentions. The Court ordered the Church Trust to be given 120 days to present a proper redevelopment scheme.
What was the impact of the 2018 Amendment to the Slum Areas Act on the case?
The 2018 Amendment did not weaken the preferential right of landowners; instead, it strengthened it by incorporating owners into the statutory framework. The Court found that no valid notice was issued to the Church Trust, preserving its preferential right.
How did the Court address the issue of collusion between Saldanha Real Estate and the SRA?
The Court found evidence of collusion between Saldanha Real Estate, Shri Kadeshwari CHS Ltd., and the SRA. The rejection of the Church Trust's proposal on technical grounds while accepting similar proposals from Saldanha indicated bias and malafide intentions.
What are the implications of this decision for future slum rehabilitation projects in Mumbai?
This decision reaffirms the priority rights of landowners in slum redevelopment projects, protecting them against opportunistic and collusive tendencies in the real estate industry. It ensures that the rights of landowners and the needs of slum dwellers are balanced, promoting fair and just urban development in Mumbai.
Related News Articles
Sunteck Realty Reports Net Profit of Rs 101.33 Crore in Q4 FY24
Sunteck Realty's net consolidated total income stood at Rs 434.99 crore in Q4 FY24
Due Process Must be Followed by Trademark Registrars in Examining Cases
The Mumbai High Court has ordered the Trademark Registry to re-examine a case involving the transfer of ownership of two trademarks, highlighting the importance of following due process in such cases.
Prestige Estates to Launch 43 New Real Estate Projects Across 7 Cities
The company has a total land bank of 260 acres across Bengaluru, Mangaluru, Mysuru, and Pune.
Pune Real Estate Firm Falls Victim to Rs 24 Lakh Cyber Fraud
An employee from the accounts department of a Pune-based real estate firm was tricked into transferring Rs 24 lakh to fraudulent accounts after receiving a message from someone posing as the company director’s father. The incident highlights the increasin
How REITs and Fractional Ownership are Reshaping the Real Estate Market
With minimum investment thresholds ranging from Rs 10-25 lakh, retail investors now have the opportunity to participate in the real estate market with limited capital.
Bombay High Court Allows Adani Electricity to Cut 209 Mangroves for Infrastructure Project
The Bombay High Court has issued a ruling permitting Adani Electricity Mumbai Infra Ltd. (AEMIL) to cut down 209 mangroves near Vasai Creek for a critical infrastructure project.